I am somewhere between 1 and 2, but I would argue there is a different subset of 1.
I buy fun cars in part based on 'Ring lap times. I track frequently, and I have done hot laps at Nürburgring myself. So to me the time means something based on my own experiences. But the "feel", "engagement" and "character" is also very important to me. This is why I can't fathom having an EV. I also realize that well driven fast car is faster than well driven slow car. So Driver Mod is key.
I am also a purists who loves NA V8s, and I refuse to own an automatic transmission, or dual-clutch, or anything without 3 pedals.
So what do I drive for fun today? A 2018 Camaro SS 1LE with a BIIIG V8 and a manual. Checks all boxes for me.