[Menez]

A BMW M135i is a better SPORTS CAR than a Porsche Boxster?? Are you kidding me?

The Porsche Boxster is beautiful and wonderfully dynamic, while the BMW M135i just looks WRONG. Since the whole point of the comparo was to see which is the best sports car, it should have been the Boxster, no questions asked. After all, the engine is where it should be in a car (My apologies, 911), and it is also naturally aspirated. And with looks reminiscent of the gorgeous Carrera GT, why would any other car even be considered?

If the only thing they could say against the Boxster was that it didn't surprise them that it was perfect, then that still means it's perfect!

Don't get me wrong though, the BMW M135i is a great car and deserves the all the praise it gets...just not "Sports Car of the Year" when a Boxster is its opponent. If it had been just "Car of the Year," I would have picked the BMW because it is a much better blend of sportiness, practicality, and price.